ARCHIVED - Financial Statements - March 31, 2011

Archived Content

Information identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards and has not been altered or updated since it was archived. Please contact us to request a format other than those available.

Table of contents

Independent Auditor’s Report

To the National Research Council of Canada and the Minister of Industry

Report on the Financial Statements

I have audited the accompanying financial statements of the National Research Council of Canada, which comprise the statement of financial position as at 31 March 2011, and the statement of operations, statement of equity of Canada and statement of cash flow for the year then ended, and a summary of significant accounting policies and other explanatory information.

Management’s Responsibility for the Financial Statements

Management is responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of these financial statements in accordance with Canadian public sector accounting standards, and for such internal control as management determines is necessary to enable the preparation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.

Auditor’s Responsibility

My responsibility is to express an opinion on these financial statements based on my audit. I conducted my audit in accordance with Canadian generally accepted auditing standards. Those standards require that I comply with ethical requirements and plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements are free from material misstatement.

An audit involves performing procedures to obtain audit evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. The procedures selected depend on the auditor’s judgment, including the assessment of the risks of material misstatement of the financial statements, whether due to fraud or error. In making those risk assessments, the auditor considers internal control relevant to the entity’s preparation and fair presentation of the financial statements in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the entity’s internal control. An audit also includes evaluating the appropriateness of accounting policies used and the reasonableness of accounting estimates made by management, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the financial statements.

I believe that the audit evidence I have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for my audit opinion.

Opinion

In my opinion, the financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of the National Research Council of Canada as at 31 March 2011, and the results of its operations and its cash flows for the year then ended in accordance with Canadian public sector accounting standards.

Report on Other Legal and Regulatory Requirements

In my opinion, the transactions of the National Research Council of Canada that have come to my notice during my audit of the financial statements have, in all significant respects, been in accordance with the Financial Administration Act and regulations, the National Research Council Act and regulations and the by-laws of the National Research Council of Canada.

John Apt, CA
Principal
for the Auditor General of Canada

22 February 2012
Ottawa, Canada

Statement of Management Responsibility Including Internal Control Over Financial Reporting

Responsibility for the integrity and objectivity of the accompanying financial statements for the year ended March 31, 2011, and all information contained in these statements rests with the management of the National Research Council Canada (NRC). These financial statements have been prepared by management in accordance with Treasury Board accounting policies, which are based on Canadian generally accepted accounting principles for the public sector.

Management is responsible for the integrity and objectivity of the information in these financial statements. Some of the information in the financial statements is based on management's best estimates and judgement, and gives due consideration to materiality. To fulfill its accounting and reporting responsibilities, management maintains a set of accounts that provides a centralized record of NRC’s financial transactions. Financial information submitted in the preparation of the Public Accounts of Canada, and included in NRC’s Departmental Performance Report, is consistent with these financial statements.

Management is also responsible for maintaining an effective system of internal control over financial reporting designed to provide reasonable assurance that financial information is reliable, that assets are safeguarded and that transactions are properly authorized and recorded in accordance with the Financial Administration Act and other applicable legislation, regulations, authorities and policies.

Management seeks to ensure the objectivity and integrity of data in its financial statements through careful selection, training, and development of qualified staff; through organizational arrangements that provide appropriate divisions of responsibility; through communication programs aimed at ensuring that regulations, policies, standards, and managerial authorities are understood throughout NRC; and through conducting an annual assessment of the effectiveness of the system of internal control over financial reporting.

An assessment for the year ended March 31, 2011 was completed in accordance with the Treasury Board Policy on Internal Control and the results and action plans are summarized in annex.

The system of internal control over financial reporting is designed to mitigate risks to a reasonable level based on an on-going process to identify key risks, to assess the effectiveness of associated key controls, and to make any necessary adjustments.

The effectiveness and adequacy of NRC’s system of internal control is reviewed by the work of internal audit staff, who conduct periodic audits of different areas of NRC's operations, and by the NRC Departmental Audit Committee, which oversees management's responsibilities for maintaining adequate control systems and the quality of financial reporting, and which recommends the financial statements to the President.

The Office of the Auditor General, the independent auditor for the Government of Canada, has expressed an opinion on the fair presentation of the financial statements of NRC which does not include an audit opinion on the annual assessment of the effectiveness of NRC's internal controls over financial reporting.

John R. McDougall, P.Eng.
President
Michel Piché, M.P.A., CMA, CIA
Vice-President, Corporate Management
and Chief Financial Officer

Ottawa, Canada
February 22, 2012

National Research Council Canada
Statement of Financial Position
as at March 31

(in thousands of dollars)
2011 2010
ASSETS
Financial Assets
Due from the Consolidated Revenue Fund
197,300 197,426
Accounts receivable and advances (Note 4)
25,806 18,892
Inventory for resale
2,192 3,001
Equity investments (Note 5)
472 252
Endowment fund investments (Note 6)
4,631 4,515
Total financial assets 230,401 224,086
Non-Financial Assets
Prepaid expenses
11,498 10,344
Inventory for consumption
4,757 3,409
Tangible capital assets (Note 7)
573,723 579,084
Total non-financial assets 589,978 592,837
TOTAL ASSETS 820,379 816,923
LIABILITIES AND EQUITY OF CANADA
Liabilities
Accounts payable and accrued liabilities (Note 8)
139,331 144,332
Vacation pay and compensatory leave
38,531 43,032
Deferred revenue (Note 9)
63,731 79,507
Lease obligations for tangible capital assets (Note 10)
213 277
Employee future benefits (Note 11)
71,099 69,004
Total liabilities 312,905 336,152
Equity of Canada 507,474 480,771
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY OF CANADA 820,379 816,923

Contingent liabilities (Note 12)
Contractual obligations (Note 13)
Net debt indicator (Note 14)

The accompanying notes form an integral part of these financial statements.

John R. McDougall, P.Eng.
President
Michel Piché, M.P.A., CMA, CIA
Vice-President, Corporate Management
and Chief Financial Officer

Ottawa, Canada
February 22, 2012

National Research Council Canada
Statement of Operations
for the year ended March 31

(in thousands of dollars)
2011 2010
Expenses
Manufacturing Technologies
177,531 183,576
Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) and Emerging Technologies
92,599 90,882
Industrial Research Assistance
288,983 290,101
Health and Life Sciences Technologies
141,336 139,536
Energy and Environmental Technologies
53,631 55,997
National Science and Technology Infrastructure
103,509 109,215
Scientific, Technical and Medical Information
27,013 37,982
Internal Services
116,029 114,150
Total Expenses 1,000,631 1,021,439
Revenues
Manufacturing Technologies
76,014 65,204
Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) and Emerging Technologies
20,425 11,519
Industrial Research Assistance
1,206 18,584
Health and Life Sciences Technologies
32,381 25,152
Energy and Environmental Technologies
17,721 14,524
National Science and Technology Infrastructure
10,413 7,866
Scientific, Technical and Medical Information
3,959 5,286
Internal Services
7,666 10,347
Total Revenues 169,785 158,482
Net Cost from Continuing Operations 830,846 862,957
Net Cost from Discontinued Operations (Note 19) 723 68
Net Cost of Operations 831,569 863,025

Segmented Information (Note 16)

The accompanying notes form an integral part of these financial statements.

National Research Council Canada
Statement of Equity of Canada
for the year ended March 31

(in thousands of dollars)
Equity of Canada 2011 2010
Beginning of year 480,771 491,370
Net cost of operations
(831,569) (863,025)
Net cash provided by Government
825,029 809,673
Change in due from the Consolidated Revenue Fund
(126) 8,130
Services provided without charge by other government departments and agencies (Note 15)
33,369 34,623
End of year 507,474 480,771

The accompanying notes form an integral part of these financial statements.

National Research Council Canada
Statement of Cash Flow
for the year ended March 31

(in thousands of dollars)
2011 2010
Operating Activities
Net cost of operations
831,569 863,025
Non-cash items
Amortization of tangible capital assets
(67,203) (67,879)
Gain on sale of equity investments
133 2,969
Net loss on disposal of tangible capital assets
(1,247) (2,221)
Services provided without charge by other government departments and agencies (Note 15)
(33,369) (34,623)
Other
1,190 143
Variations in Statement of Financial Position
Increase (decrease) in accounts receivable and advances
6,914 (7,779)
(Decrease) increase in inventory for resale
(809) 820
Increase in equity investment
220 0
Increase in endowment fund investments
116 96
Increase (decrease) in prepaid expenses
1,154 (1,756)
Increase in inventory for consumption
1,348 554
Decrease (increase) in liabilities
23,247 (6,209)
Cash used in operating activities (including discontinued operations) 763,263 747,140
Capital Investing Activities
Acquisitions of tangible capital assets
62,283 66,867
Acquisitions not affecting cash and transfers to inventory for resale
0 (676)
Proceeds from disposal of tangible capital assets
(384) (282)
Cash used in capital investing activities 61,899 65,909
Investing Activities
Proceeds from sale of equity investments
(133) (3,376)
Cash used in investing activities (133) (3,376)
Net cash provided by Government of Canada 825,029 809,673

The accompanying notes form an integral part of these financial statements.

National Research Council Canada
Notes to Financial Statements
Year ended March 31, 2011

1. Authority and Objectives

The National Research Council Canada (NRC) exists under the National Research Council Act and is a departmental corporation named in Schedule II of the Financial Administration Act. The mission of NRC is to work with clients and partners to provide strategic research, scientific and technical services to develop and deploy solutions to meet Canada's current and future industrial and societal needs.

In delivering its mandate, NRC reports under the following program activities:

  • Manufacturing Technologies: Multidisciplinary research and development in consultation with industry, universities, government departments and other key innovation players to improve the global competitiveness of Canadian industry by transforming knowledge and innovation into real economic value and by transferring technologies into industrial solutions for the marketplace.
  • Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) and Emerging Technologies: Mobilizes, collaborates and partners with key university, government and private sector players and forms major research collaborations to develop integrated research solutions in the areas of information and communications technologies and emerging technologies.
  • Industrial Research Assistance: Provides a range of technical and business-oriented advisory services, as well as financial support for small and medium-sized Canadian businesses engaged in research and development of technological innovations to augment their capacity and capability to innovate, commercialize and generate significant economic activity for Canadian Industry.
  • Health and Life Science Technologies: Mobilizes and partners with key university, government and private sector players and forms major research collaborations to develop integrated research solutions for complex health and related life science issues.
  • Energy and Environmental Technologies: In partnership with other government departments, universities and industry, brings together the knowledge and expertise needed to make an impact on areas of critical importance to Canada in environmental and sustainable energy.
  • National Science and Technology Infrastructure: Manages national science and engineering facilities and infrastructure critical to research, development and innovation by Canadian scientific and technological communities.
  • Scientific, Technical and Medical Information: Operates and maintains the national science library, specifically holding the national collection of Scientific, Technical and Medical information, to facilitate knowledge discovery, cross discipline research, innovation and commercialization.
  • Internal Services: Groups of activities and resources administered to support the needs of programs and other corporate obligations of the organization. Includes only those activities and resources that apply across the organization and not to those provided specifically to a program.

2. Summary of Significant Accounting Policies

These financial statements have been prepared in accordance with Treasury Board accounting policies stated below, which are based on Canadian generally accepted accounting principles for the public sector. The presentation and results using the stated accounting policies do not result in any significant differences from Canadian generally accepted accounting principles, except as disclosed in Note 14 - Net Debt Indicator.

Significant accounting policies are as follows:

  1. Parliamentary authorities

    NRC is financed mainly by the Government of Canada through Parliamentary authorities. Financial reporting of authorities provided to NRC do not parallel financial reporting according to generally accepted accounting principles since authorities are primarily based on cash flow requirements. Consequently, items recognized in the Statement of Operations and the Statement of Financial Position are not necessarily the same as those provided through authorities from Parliament. Note 3 provides a reconciliation between the bases of reporting.

  2. Net Cash Provided by Government

    NRC operates within the Consolidated Revenue Fund (CRF), which is administered by the Receiver General for Canada. All cash received by NRC is deposited to the CRF and all cash disbursements made by NRC are paid from the CRF. The net cash provided by Government is the difference between all cash receipts and all cash disbursements including transactions between departments (including agencies) of the Government.

  3. Amounts due from/to the CRF

    Amounts due from/to the CRF are the result of timing differences at year-end between the time when a transaction affects authorities and when it is processed through the CRF. Amounts due from the CRF represent the net amount of cash that NRC is entitled to draw from the CRF without further authorities to discharge its liabilities.

  4. Revenues

    • Receipts are deposited to the Consolidated Revenue Fund. Under the NRC Act, money received by NRC through the conduct of its operations is respendable in the current or in subsequent years.
    • Revenues are recognized in the year in which the underlying transaction or event occurred that gave rise to revenue.
    • Funds received for which NRC has an obligation to other parties for the provision of goods, services or the use of assets in the future are recorded as deferred revenue.
    • Contributions of leased tangible capital assets are deferred and amortized as Lease inducement revenue on the same basis as the related depreciable tangible capital assets.
  5. Expenses

    • Expenses are recorded on an accrual basis.
    • Grants are recognized in the year in which the conditions for payment are met. In the case of grants which do not form part of an existing program, the expense is recognized when the Government announces a decision to make a non-recurring transfer, provided the enabling legislation or authorization for payment receives parliamentary approval prior to the completion of the financial statements.
    • Contributions are recognized in the year in which the recipient has met the eligibility criteria or fulfilled the terms of a contractual transfer agreement, provided that the transfer is authorized and a reasonable estimate can be made.
    • Vacation pay and compensatory leave are accrued as the benefits are earned by employees under their respective terms of employment.
    • Services provided without charge by other government departments and agencies for accommodation, employer contributions to the health and dental insurance plans, audit of NRC’s financial statements, legal services and workers' compensation are recorded as operating expenses at their estimated cost and credited directly to equity.
  6. Employee future benefits

    1. Pension Benefits

      Eligible employees participate in the Public Service Pension Plan, a multiemployer plan administered by the Government of Canada. NRC’s contributions to the Plan are charged to expenses in the year incurred and represent NRC’s total obligation to the Plan. Current legislation does not require NRC to make contributions for any actuarial deficiencies of the Plan.

    2. Severance Benefits

      Employees are entitled to severance benefits under labour contracts or conditions of employment. These benefits are accrued as employees render the services necessary to earn them. The obligation relating to the benefits earned by employees is calculated using information derived from the results of the actuarially determined liability for employee severance benefits for the Government as a whole.
  7. Accounts receivable

    Accounts receivable are stated at the lower of cost and net recoverable value; a valuation allowance is recorded for receivables where recovery is considered uncertain.

  8. Conditionally repayable contributions

    Conditionally repayable contributions are contributions that, all or part of which become repayable, if conditions specified in the contribution agreement come into effect. Accordingly, they are not recorded on the Statement of Financial Position until the conditions specified in the agreement come into effect, at which time they are recorded as a receivable and a reduction in transfer payment expenses. An estimated allowance for uncollectibility is recorded where appropriate.

  9. Contingent liabilities

    Contingent liabilities are potential liabilities, which may become actual liabilities when one or more future events occur or fail to occur. To the extent that the future event is likely to occur or fail to occur, and a reasonable estimate of the loss can be made, an estimated liability is accrued and an expense recorded. If the likelihood is not determinable or an amount cannot be reasonably estimated, the contingency is disclosed in the notes to the financial statements.

  10. Environmental liabilities

    Environmental liabilities reflect the estimated costs related to the management and remediation of environmentally contaminated sites. Based on management's best estimates, a liability is accrued and an expense recorded when the contamination occurs or when NRC becomes aware of the contamination and is obligated, or is likely to be obligated to incur such costs. If the likelihood of NRC's obligation to incur these costs is not determinable, or if an amount cannot be reasonably estimated, the costs are disclosed as contingent liabilities in the notes to the financial statements.

  11. Inventories

    Inventory for resale and for consumption is recorded at the lower of cost (using the average cost method) or net realizable value. The cost is charged to operations in the year in which the items are sold or used.

  12. Equity investments

    Equity investments include shares in public and privately-held companies. Equity investments are typically obtained as a result of debt settlement negotiations or as a result of non-monetary transactions (where financial assistance at better-than-market conditions was provided to firms through access to intellectual property, equipment and incubation space in laboratories). If the estimates of the non-monetary transactions cannot be determined, the equity investments are initially recorded at a nominal value. Otherwise they are initially recorded at fair value based on market prices. If the fair value of equity investments becomes lower than the book value and this decline in value is considered to be other than temporary, the equity investments are written down to fair value.

  13. Endowment fund investments

    Endowments consist of donations subject to externally imposed restrictions stipulating that the resources be maintained permanently. Income from the investment of endowments may only be used for the purposes established by the donors.

    Endowments are recognized as an asset when the amount to be received can be reasonably estimated and ultimate collection is reasonably assured.

    Funds received for endowments are invested in bonds and are carried at amortized cost. The premium or discount determined at the time of acquisition is amortized until the security’s maturity. Fair value of bonds is based on market prices.

  14. Foreign currency transactions

    Transactions involving foreign currencies are translated into Canadian dollar equivalents using rates of exchange in effect at the time of those transactions. Monetary assets and liabilities denominated in a foreign currency are translated into Canadian dollars using the rate of exchange in effect at year end. Gains and losses resulting from foreign currency transactions are included in the applicable line on the Statement of Operations according to the activities to which they relate. Net gains and losses relating to the sale of goods or services denominated in a foreign currency are included in revenues. Net gains and losses relating to the purchase of goods or services denominated in a foreign currency are included in expenses. Contractual obligations may contain foreign currencies that are translated into Canadian dollar equivalents using the rate of exchange in effect at March 31, 2011.

  15. Tangible capital assets

    Acquired tangible capital assets and leasehold improvements having an initial cost of $5,000 or more are recorded at their acquisition cost. Contributed tangible capital assets are recorded at market value at the date of contribution. NRC does not capitalize intangibles, works of art and historical treasures that have cultural, aesthetic or historical value. Assets acquired under tangible capital leases are initially recorded at the lower of the present value of the minimum lease payments at the inception of the lease or fair value. Tangible capital assets held for sale are recorded at the lower of their carrying value or fair value less cost to sell and no amortization is recorded.

    Amortization of tangible capital assets is calculated on a straight-line basis over the estimated useful life of the asset as follows:

    Asset Class Amortization Period
    Land Not applicable
    Buildings and facilities 25 years
    Works and infrastructure 25 - 40 years
    Machinery, equipment and furniture 10 years
    Informatics equipment 5 years
    Informatics software 5 years
    Vehicles 7 years
    Aircraft 15 - 30 years
    Leasehold improvements Lesser of the remaining term of the lease or useful life of the improvement
    Leased tangible capital assets In accordance with asset class

    Assets under construction are recorded in the applicable capital asset class in the year that they become available for use and are not amortized until they become available for use.

    Where NRC enters into land leases at a nominal value, the transaction is considered as a non-monetary transaction and is recorded at fair value. Fair value of the transaction is based on market prices. If the estimates of the non-monetary transactions cannot be determined, the amount of the transaction is recorded at a nominal value.

  16. Measurement uncertainty

    The preparation of these financial statements requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets, liabilities, revenues and expenses reported in the financial statements. At the time of preparation of these statements, management believes the estimates and assumptions to be reasonable. The most significant items where estimates are used are percentage of completion on revenue from the provision of services, contingent liabilities, contaminated site liabilities, the liability for employee severance benefits, the allowance for doubtful accounts, the fair value of non-monetary transactions related to leased tangible capital assets and the useful life of tangible capital assets. Actual results could significantly differ from those estimated. Management's estimates are reviewed periodically and, as adjustments become necessary, they are recorded in the financial statements in the year they become known.

  17. Asset retirement obligations

    Liabilities are recognized for statutory, contractual or legal obligations, when incurred, associated with the retirement of tangible capital assets when those obligations result from the acquisition, construction, development or normal operation of the assets. The obligations are measured initially at fair value, determined using present value methodology, and the resulting costs capitalized into the carrying amount of the related asset. In subsequent periods, the liability is adjusted for the accretion of discount and any changes in the amount or timing of the underlying future cash flows. The capitalized asset retirement cost is depreciated on the same basis as the related asset and the discount accretion is included in determining the results of operations.

3. Parliamentary Authorities

NRC receives most of its funding through annual Parliamentary authorities. Items recognized in the Statement of Operations and the Statement of Financial Position in one year may be funded through Parliamentary authorities in prior, current or future years. Accordingly, NRC has different net results of operations for the year on a government funding basis than on an accrual accounting basis. The differences are reconciled in the following tables:

  1. Reconciliation of net cost of operations to current year authorities used

    (in thousands of dollars)
    2011 2010
    Net Cost of Operations 831,569 863,025
    Adjustments for items affecting net cost of operations but not affecting authorities (including discontinued operations):
    Revenues
    176,959 169,627
    Amortization of tangible capital assets
    (67,203) (67,879)
    Financial arrangements with other government departments and agencies
    (57,978) (70,266)
    Services provided without charge by other government departments and agencies(Note 15)
    (33,369) (34,623)
    Specified purpose accounts expenses
    (20,856) (16,491)
    Decrease in salary accrual
    4,532 8,978
    Decrease in vacation pay and compensatory leave
    4,501 5,904
    Refunds of previous year's expenditures
    3,180 1,362
    (Increase) decrease in employee future benefits
    (2,095) 6,071
    Cost of goods sold
    (1,732) (696)
    Loss on disposal of tangible capital assets
    (1,247) (2,221)
    Other
    1,064 596
    (Increase) decrease in accrued liability
    (431) 309
    Decrease in inventory
    (430) (9)
    Decrease in litigation claim expense accrual
    375 675
    Decrease (increase) in contaminated sites liabilities
    203 (30)
    Bad debt expense
    (136) (689)
    Total items affecting net cost of operations but not affecting authorities (including discontinued operations)
    5,337 618
    Adjustments for items not affecting net cost of operations but affecting authorities:
    Acquisitions of tangible capital assets and additions to assets under construction
    60,801 65,565
    Inventory purchases
    2,777 1,204
    Contaminated sites remediation reducing the liability
    1,597 2,299
    Increase (decrease) in prepaid expenses
    1,154 (1,756)
    Decrease in lease obligations for tangible capital assets
    63 59
    Total adjustments for items not affecting net cost of operations but affecting authorities 66,392 67,371
    Current year authorities used 903,298 931,014
  2. Reconciliation of Parliamentary authorities provided and used
    (in thousands of dollars)
    2011 2010
    Parliamentary appropriations provided:
    Vote 60 – Operating expenditures
    427,947 438,567
    Vote 65 – Capital expenditures
    53,192 52,597
    Vote 70 – Grants and contributions
    294,888 274,579
    Statutory amounts:
    Revenues pursuant to paragraph 5(1)(e) of the National Research Council Act
    123,255 155,956
    Contributions to employee benefit plans
    63,681 67,902
    Proceeds from the disposal of surplus Crown assets
    594 441
    Collection agency fees
    25 27
    Less:
    Revenues available for use in future years
    (48,316) (46,009)
    Lapsed authorities:
    Frozen allotments - Operating
    (4,327) (8,075)
    Frozen allotments - Capital
    (3,198) (1,388)
    Frozen allotments - Grants and Contributions
    (410) 0
    Unexpended authorities - Grants and Contributions
    (3,581) (3,543)
    Unexpended authorities - Capital
    (328) 0
    Unexpended authorities - Operating
    (124) (40)
    Current year authorities used 903,298 931,014

4. Accounts Receivable and Advances

The following table presents details of NRC's accounts receivables and advances balances:

(in thousands of dollars)
Accounts Receivables and Advances 2011 2010
Receivables from external parties 19,177 15,443
Receivables from other government departments and agencies 5,143 2,309
Employee advances 36 40
Total accounts receivable and advances before allowance for doubtful accounts 24,356 17,792
Less: allowance for doubtful accounts on receivables from external parties (682) (856)
Total less allowance for doubtful accounts on receivables from external parties 23,674 16,936
Repayable contributions 7,820 10,586
Less: allowance for uncollectibility (5,688) (8,630)
Net repayable contributions 2,132 1,956
Total 25,806 18,892

5. Equity Investments

Equity investments include shares in three publicly held companies (three in 2010) and two privately held companies (thirteen in 2010). These shares were obtained through debt settlement or non-monetary transactions. NRC will consider timely opportunities for divestiture of equity investments by taking into account the interests, market liquidity and expected future growth of the applicable company.

During the year, NRC sold shares for $132,679 ($3,376,391 in 2010) realizing a gain of $132,678 ($2,968,969 in 2010). NRC also received shares in a public company in exchange for debt settlement of $219,889 (nil in 2010). No companies in which NRC holds equity investments were declared bankrupt or inactive during the year (nine in 2010).

As at March 31, 2011, the book value of the equity investments was $471,953 ($252,076 in 2010). The market value of NRC’s equity investments in publicly held companies was $281,123 ( $171,967 in 2010). The market value of the privately held companies is not determinable.

6. Endowment Fund Investments

This account was established pursuant to paragraph 5(1)(f) of the National Research Council Act to record the residue of the estate of the late H.L. Holmes. Up to two thirds of the endowment fund's yearly net income is used to finance the H.L. Holmes award on an annual basis. The award provides the opportunity to post-doctoral students to study at world famous graduate schools or research institutes under outstanding researchers.

(in thousands of dollars)
Restricted cash and investments 2011 2010
Beginning of year 4,515 4,419
Net income from endowment 213 213
Awards granted (97) (117)
End of year 4,631 4,515

The portfolio had an average effective return of 4.70% (5.07% in 2010) and an average term to maturity of 5.18 years as at March 31, 2011 (5.52 years as at March 31, 2010). The fair value of the endowment investments as at March 31, 2011 was $4,775,354 ($4,653,482 in 2010).

7. Tangible Capital Assets

(in thousands of dollars)
Cost Accumulated Amortization Net Book Value
Tangible capital asset class Opening balance Acquisitions Transfers, disposals and write-offs Closing balance Opening balance Amortization Transfers, disposals and write-offs Closing balance 2011 Net book value 2010 Net book value
Land 9,879 0 0 9,879 0 0 0 0 9,879 9,879
Buildings and facilities 655,870 18,711 9,795 684,376 (386,849) (21,509) 23 (408,335) 276,041 269,021
Works and infrastructure 21,682 110 0 21,792 (14,457) (654) 0 (15,111) 6,681 7,225
Machinery, equipment and furniture 513,002 14,776 (3,850) 523,928 (335,674) (34,620) 14,705 (355,589) 168,339 177,328
Informatics equipment 63,628 3,467 (6,015) 61,080 (51,810) (4,354) 6,786 (49,378) 11,702 11,818
Informatics software 21,767 971 (4,033) 18,705 (13,298) (2,659) 4,000 (11,957) 6,748 8,469
Vehicles 3,170 49 (184) 3,035 (2,407) (151) 177 (2,381) 654 763
Aircraft 11,294 66 0 11,360 (9,866) (118) 0 (9,984) 1,376 1,428
Leasehold improvements 12,808 49 0 12,857 (3,206) (567) 0 (3,773) 9,084 9,602
Assets under construction 32,961 24,084 (22,181) 34,864 0 0 0 0 34,864 32,961
Leased tangible capital assets 63,700 0 336 64,036 (13,110) (2,571) 0 (15,681) 48,355 50,590
Total 1,409,761 62,283 (26,132) 1,445,912 (830,677) (67,203) 25,691 (872,189) 573,723 579,084

When assets under construction are put into use during the fiscal year, they are transferred out of Assets under construction and into the capital asset class to which they relate, from which point on they are amortized as applicable.

Amortization expense for the year ended March 31, 2011 is $67,202,810 ($67,879,472 in 2010).

At March 31, 2011, NRC held eight land lease agreements (eight in 2010) for a nominal annual cost of one dollar with universities. In these instances, NRC owns the building on the leased land. The fair value of the land leases for these non-monetary transactions could not be determined at the inception of the lease therefore they are recorded at a nominal value.

On March 21, 1996, NRC entered into a non-monetary transaction consisting of a lease agreement with the University of Western Ontario for the relocation of the Integrated Manufacturing Technologies Institute (IMTI), whereby leased property was provided to NRC for twenty-five years at a nominal cost of one dollar. Since the inception of the lease agreement, IMTI was restructured under NRC's Industrial Materials Institute (IMI) and NRC's Institute for Research in Construction. NRC has no obligations to the University of Western Ontario other than the relocation of the institute. The property was recorded as a leased tangible capital asset at its fair value of $10,000,000. The annual amortization of $400,000 for the leased tangible capital asset is exactly offset by the amortization of the deferred contribution related to the leased property.

On May 23, 2006, NRC took possession of a new facility and entered into a non-monetary transaction with the University of Alberta. NRC entered into a lease agreement with the University for the housing of NRC’s National Institute for Nanotechnology (NINT), whereby leased property is provided to NRC at a nominal cost of one dollar per year. The lease provides a one year term with options to renew on ten sequential occasions, each of the first nine renewals to be for a period of five years and the tenth renewal for a period of four years. The building was recorded as a leased tangible capital asset at its fair value of $44,400,000. The annual amortization of $1,776,000 for the leased tangible capital asset is exactly offset by the amortization of the deferred contribution related to the leased building.

On September 1, 2006, NRC took possession of a new facility and entered into a non-monetary transaction with the University of Prince Edward Island. NRC entered into a lease agreement with the University for the housing of NRC’s Institute for Nutrisciences and Health (INH), whereby leased property was provided to NRC at a nominal cost of one dollar per year. The lease provides a nineteen month term with renewal options for seven additional periods of five years, and one additional period of three years and five months (to August 31, 2046). The building was recorded as a leased tangible capital asset at its fair value of $9,300,000. The annual amortization of $372,000 for the leased tangible capital asset is exactly offset by the amortization of the deferred contribution related to the leased building.

8. Accounts Payable and Accrued Liabilities

The following table presents details of the NRC's accounts payable and accrued liabilities:

(in thousands of dollars)
Accounts Payable and Accrued Liabilities 2011 2010
Suppliers and contributions payable 108,612 104,421
Payable to other government departments and agencies 21,271 25,641
Accrued wages and employee benefits 8,248 11,495
Contractor holdbacks 1,036 814
Contaminated site liabilities 80 1,880
Sales tax payable 84 81
Total 139,331 144,332

9. Deferred Revenue

Deferred revenue represents amounts received from external parties for which NRC has a future obligation for the provision of goods, services or the use of assets. Revenue is recognized in the period that goods are delivered or services are provided. A summary of the transactions related to this account are as follows:

(in thousands of dollars)
2011 2010
Deferred revenue – contributions related to leased tangible capital assets
Balance, beginning of year 50,590 53,138
Contributions recognized as revenue (2,548) (2,548)
Balance, end of year 48,042 50,590
Deferred revenue - specified purpose accounts
Balance, beginning of year 20,618 17,060
Funds received 21,713 22,271
Revenue recognized (32,569) (18,713)
Balance, end of year 9,762 20,618
Deferred revenue - specified purpose accounts
Balance, beginning of year 8,299 6,972
Funds received 4,838 8,868
Revenue recognized (7,210) (7,541)
Balance, end of year 5,927 8,299
Total 63,731 79,507

10. Lease obligation for tangible capital assets

NRC has entered into an agreement to lease mechanical test equipment under capital lease with a cost of $336,000 and accumulated amortization of $22,400 as at March 31, 2011 ($336,000 and $0 in 2010). The obligations related to the upcoming years include the following:

(in thousands of dollars)
2011 2010
2011 n/a 80
2012 80 80
2013 80 80
2014 80 80
Total future minimum lease payments 240 240
Less: imputed interest (6.11%) (27) (43)
Balance of obligations under leased tangible capital assets 213 277

11. Employee Future Benefits

Employees of NRC are entitled to specific benefits on or after termination or retirement, as provided for under various collective agreements or conditions of employment.

  1. Pension benefits

    Eligible NRC employees participate in the Public Service Pension Plan, which is sponsored and administered by the Government. Pension benefits accrue up to a maximum of 35 years at a rate of two percent per year of pensionable service, times the average of the best five consecutive years of earnings. The benefits are integrated with Canada/Quebec Pension Plans benefits and they are indexed to inflation.

    Both the employees and NRC contribute to the cost of the Plan. The expense amounts to $44,702,888 as at March 31, 2011 ($49,024,953 in 2010), which represents approximately 1.9 times (1.9 times in 2010) the contributions by employees.

    NRC’s responsibility with regard to the Plan is limited to its contributions. Actuarial surpluses or deficiencies are recognized in the financial statements of the Government of Canada, as the Plan’s sponsor.

  2. Severance benefits

    NRC provides severance benefits to its employees based on eligibility, years of service and final salary. These severance benefits are not pre-funded. Benefits will be paid from future authorities. Information about the severance benefits, measured as at March 31, is as follows:

    (in thousands of dollars)
    Accrued benefit obligation 2011 2010
    Beginning of year 69,004 75,075
    Increase (decrease) of the accrued expense for the year 9,845 (965)
    Benefits paid during the year (7,750) (5,106)
    End of year 71,099 69,004

12. Contingent Liabilities

Contingent liabilities arise in the normal course of operations and their ultimate disposition is unknown. They are grouped into these three categories as follows:

  1. Contaminated sites

    During 2010-11, NRC completed extensive remediation work at specific contaminated sites. Liabilities are accrued to record the estimated costs related to the management and remediation of contaminated sites where NRC is obligated or likely to be obligated to incur such costs. For 2011, NRC has identified four sites (two sites in 2010) where such action is possible and for which a liability of $79,829 ($1,880,195 in 2010) has been recorded in accrued liabilities. The estimate has been prepared using current market rates and is based on the results of initial testing performed by NRC at suspect sites. NRC has identified one additional site with contaminants exceeding an environmental standard and for which NRC may be responsible to incur remediation costs. This site is still under investigation and NRC is presently unable to determine the amount of the remediation liability, if any. NRC’s ongoing efforts to assess contaminated sites may result in additional environmental liabilities related to newly identified sites, or changes in the assessments or intended use of existing sites. These liabilities will be accrued by NRC in the year in which they become likely and are reasonably estimable.

  2. Claims and litigation

    Claims have been made against NRC in the normal course of operations. Legal proceedings for six claims were pending at March 31, 2011 (eleven in 2010). NRC has no claim that will likely result in a liability (one in 2010) for which no accrued liability ($375,000 in 2010) has been recorded based on NRC’s legal assessment of potential liability. NRC has one claim where the outcome is undeterminable (two in 2010). Some of these potential liabilities may become actual liabilities when one or more future events occur or fail to occur. To the extent that the future event is likely to occur or fail to occur, and a reasonable estimate of the loss can be made, an estimated liability is accrued and an expense recorded in the financial statements.

  3. Asset Retirement Obligations

    As at March 31, 2011 NRC has recognized an asset retirement obligation of $253,000 ($221,000 in 2010) in the financial statements as a result of its legal obligation to retire storage tank systems for petroleum products and allied petroleum products. The undiscounted amount of expected future cash flows required to settle the asset retirement obligation is estimated at $452,000 ($463,000 in 2010). The liability for the expected future cash flows, as reflected in the financial statements, has been discounted at a weighted average of 3.77% (4.74% in 2010) based on the Government of Canada benchmark bonds. This obligation will be settled over the useful lives of the operating assets. The following table summarizes the changes in the asset retirement obligations:

    (in thousands of dollars)
    Asset retirement obligations 2011 2010
    Beginning of year 221 216
    Accretion of asset retirement obligations 32 5
    End of year 253 221

    Other asset retirement obligations, such as the costs associated with the removal and disposal of asbestos and other designated substances located in NRC buildings have not been recognized in the financial statements due to the fact that they are subject to several uncertainties. NRC generally incurs the cost of removing and disposing regulated substances during major building renovations; consequently the timing and scope of these renovations cannot be reasonably estimated at this time and therefore fair values cannot be reasonably determined. Changes in these assumptions and uncertainties could materially affect NRC's assets and liabilities as well as the resulting amortization and accretion expenses related to the asset retirement obligation.

13. Contractual Obligations

The nature of NRC’s activities can result in some large multi-year contracts and obligations whereby NRC will be obligated to make future payments in order to carry out its transfer payment programs or when the services/goods are received. Significant contractual obligations that can be reasonably estimated are summarized as follows:

(in thousands of dollars)
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 and thereafter Total
Transfer payments 104,845 55,140 49,561 49,941 1,572 261,059
Operating contracts 18,789 3,291 1,551 307 0 23,938
Total 123,634 58,431 51,112 50,248 1,572 284,997

14. Net Debt Indicator

The presentation of the net debt indicator and a statement of change in net debt is required under Canadian generally accepted accounting principles.

Net debt is the difference between a government's liabilities and its financial assets and is meant to provide a measure of the future revenues required to pay for past transactions and events. A statement of change in net debt would show changes during the period in components such as tangible capital assets, prepaid expenses and inventories. NRC is financed by the Government of Canada through appropriations and respendable revenues and operates within the Consolidated Revenue Fund (CRF), which is administered by the Receiver General for Canada. All cash received by NRC is deposited to the CRF and all cash disbursements made by NRC are paid by the CRF. With the exception of endowment fund investments and receivables from other Federal Government departments, NRC's Financial Assets as well as future appropriations and respendable revenues generated by NRC's operations can be used to discharge existing liabilities.

(in thousands of dollars)
2011 2010
Liabilities
Accounts payable and accrued liabilities
139,331 144,332
Vacation pay and compensatory leave
38,531 43,032
Deferred revenue
63,731 79,507
Lease obligation for tangible capital assets
213 277
Employee future benefits
71,099 69,004
Total Liabilities 312,905 336,152
Financial Assets
Due from the Consolidated Revenue Fund
197,300 197,426
Accounts receivable and advances
25,806 18,892
Inventory for resale
2,192 3,001
Equity investments
472 252
Endowment fund investments
4,631 4,515
Total Financial Assets 230,401 224,086
Net Debt Indicator 82,504 112,066

15. Related Party Transactions

NRC is related as a result of common ownership to all Government departments, agencies, and Crown corporations. NRC enters into transactions with these entities in the normal course of business and on normal trade terms.

  1. Common services provided without charge by other government departments and agencies

    During the year, NRC received services without charge from other government departments and agencies. These services have been recognized in NRC’s Statement of Operations as follows:

    (in thousands of dollars)
    2010 2011
    Employer’s contributions to the health and dental insurance plans provided by Treasury Board 31,830 33,022
    Audit of NRC's financial statements provided by the Office of the Auditor General of Canada 614 501
    Legal services provided by Justice Canada 486 454
    Workers’ compensation benefits provided by Human Resources and Skills Development Canada 287 302
    Payroll services provided by Public Works and Government Services Canada (Note 18) 0 192
    Accommodation provided by Public Works and Government Services Canada 152 152
    Total 33,369 34,623

    The Government has centralized some of its administrative activities for efficiency, cost-effectiveness purposes and economic delivery of programs to the public. As a result, the Government uses central agencies and common service organizations so that one department performs services for all other departments and agencies without charge. The costs of these services, such as the payroll and cheque issuance services provided by Public Works and Government Services Canada, beginning in 2011 are not included in the Statement of Operations (amount not determinable in 2011, $192,000 in 2010).

  2. Other transactions with related parties

    (in thousands of dollars)
    2010 2011
    Receivable from other government departments and agencies 5,143 2,309
    Payable to other government departments and agencies 21,271 25,641
    Expenses - Other government departments and agencies 80,156 87,691
    Revenues - Other government departments and agencies 57 69

16. Segmented Information

Presentation by segment is based on NRC's program activity architecture (PAA). NRC allocates transactions over the PAA in accordance with stewardship principles, based on the Institutes, Branch or Program (IBP) that is responsible for managing the resource.

The presentation by segment is based on the same accounting policies as described in the Summary of significant accounting policies in note 2. The following table presents the expenses incurred and revenues generated for the main program activities, by major object of expenses and by major type of revenues. The segment results for the period are as follows:

(in thousands of dollars)
Manufacturing Technologies ICT and Emerging Technologies Industrial Research Assistance Health and Life Sciences Technologies Energy and Environmental Technologies National Science and Technology Infrastructure Scientific, Technical and Medical Information Internal Services 2011 Total 2010 Total
Expenses
Salaries and employee benefits
112,620 52,561 49,305 92,862 34,922 33,451 13,204 68,003 456,928 460,831
Grants and contributions
0 0 230,758 0 0 55,752 1,656 431 288,597 281,230
Utilities, materials and supplies
20,918 12,449 1,549 17,774 4,656 2,289 9,166 11,331 80,132 83,632
Amortization
21,096 13,128 137 16,019 7,393 4,435 1,119 3,763 67,090 67,340
Professional and special services
9,629 8,424 1,532 6,057 3,622 3,415 1,076 10,952 44,707 52,348
Transportation and communication
4,976 2,324 3,199 2,612 1,335 1,923 372 2,752 19,493 23,873
Repairs and maintenance
4,859 1,782 207 3,279 1,264 717 295 4,924 17,327 18,483
Payments in lieu of taxes
1,188 554 0 427 77 0 0 11,753 13,999 14,475
Rentals
1,031 661 1,923 197 83 426 51 221 4,593 4,803
Awards
207 528 5 1,732 78 38 3 82 2,673 3,104
Information
412 94 69 84 46 55 44 1,416 2,220 2,453
Cost of goods sold
462 0 0 171 0 1,014 0 55 1,702 608
Net loss (gain) on disposal of capital assets
106 52 21 108 155 (6) 27 175 638 2,221
Bad debts
0 0 278 0 0 0 0 136 414 6,032
Other
27 42 0 14 0 0 0 35 118 6
Total expenses 177,531 92,599 288,983 141,336 53,631 103,509 27,013 116,029 1,000,631 1,021,439
Revenues
Sales of goods and services
Services of non.regulatory nature and other fees and charges
27,497 4,109 0 7,475 4,200 7,038 455 3,494 54,268 48,250
Rights and privileges
800 1,809 0 6,389 474 177 0 0 9,649 8,922
Sales of goods and information products
3,476 0 0 622 0 528 0 4 4,630 3,507
Lease and use of property
558 982 0 2,375 262 7 0 445 4,629 4,449
Total sales of goods and services 32,331 6,900 0 16,861 4,936 7,750 455 3,943 73,176 65,128
Financial arrangements with other government departments and agencies
32,224 4,059 1,206 3,735 10,118 1,434 3,480 522 56,778 68,666
Revenues from joint project and cost sharing
11,459 5,405 0 11,785 2,667 1,229 24 0 32,569 18,714
Other
0 4,061 0 0 0 0 0 520 4,581 457
Lease inducement revenue
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2,548 2,548 2,548
Gain on sale of equity investment
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 133 133 2,969
Total revenues 76,014 20,425 1,206 32,381 17,721 10,413 3,959 7,666 169,785 158,482
Net cost from continuing operations 101,517 72,174 287,777 108,955 35,910 93,096 23,054 108,363 830,846 862,957

17. Financial Instruments

NRC’s financial instruments consist of accounts receivable and advances, investments and accounts payable and accrued liabilities. Unless otherwise noted, it is management’s opinion that NRC is not exposed to significant interest, currency or credit risk arising from these financial instruments. Unless otherwise disclosed in these financial statements, management estimates that the carrying values of the financial instruments approximate their fair value due to their impending maturity.

18.Change in accounting policy

During the year, NRC adopted a change in accounting policy in order to comply with the revised Treasury Board Accounting Standard (1.2) on preparation of departmental financial statements. This new standard requires that Payroll Services provided without charge by Public Works and Government Services Canada not be recorded as operating expenses. This change is being applied prospectively beginning in fiscal year 2011.

19. Discontinued Operations

On January 1, 2010, approval was made to privatize the Research Press program at NRC's Canada Institute for Scientific and Technical Information (NRC-CISTI) into a newly formed non-profit organization operated by previous employees of NRC-CISTI, effective September 1, 2010. The consideration for the privatization was $1. As part of the privatization, NRC agreed to make cash contributions of up to $2 million in support of the creation of the non-profit organization for expenses incurred up to September 1, 2010. For the fiscal year ended March 31, 2011, total contributions were $1,609,935. This amount is included in Grants and Contribution in continued operations.

As part of the privatization on September 1, 2010, $1,093,759 of inventory was disposed of as there was no further use. The following assets were transferred at their net book value:

Assets Net book value
Inventory 457,497
Informatics software 606,852
Informatics equipment 2,460

In addition, a non-competitive contract was initiated between NRC and the non-profit entity in the amount of $4 million which is included in revenue below, for the 7 month period September 1, 2010 to March 31, 2011. This was a non-cash transaction and reflects a decrease in the deferred revenue already received in relation to the fiscal year ended March 31, 2011.

The transfer and disposal of capital assets and the revenue received as part of the non-competitive contract are included in the segmented information summarized below.

The following segmented information has been removed from the Statement of Operations and Note 16-Segmented Information as part of the discontinued operations. The net amount is disclosed on the Statement of Operations as the Net Cost from Discontinued Operations:

2011 2010
Expenses 7,897,000 11,213,000
Revenues 7,174,000 11,145,000
Net 723,000 68,000

In addition to the above information, NRC has entered into a non-competitive lease agreement with the non-profit organization for use of NRC premises of up to 1,810 square meters of space for five years at no charge for the first two years. The third year of the lease agreement is below fair market value with the fourth and fifth years expected to be at fair market value. NRC has also leased the name “NRC – Research Press” to the non-profit organization.

20. Comparative Information

Comparative figures have been reclassified to conform to the current year's presentation.

Annex to the Statement of Management Responsibility including Internal Control over Financial Reporting
For the fiscal year ended March 31, 2011

Summary of the assessment of effectiveness of the system of internal control over financial reporting and the action plan of the National Research Council (NRC) for fiscal year 2010-2011

Note to the reader

With the new Treasury Board Policy on Internal Control, effective April 1, 2009, departments are required to demonstrate the measures they are taking to maintain an effective system of internal control over financial reporting (ICFR).

As part of this policy, departments are expected to conduct annual assessments of their system of ICFR, establish action plans to address any necessary adjustments, and to attach to their Statement of Management Responsibility, a summary of their assessment results and action plan.

Effective systems of ICFR aim to achieve reliable financial statements and to provide assurance that:

  • Transactions are appropriately authorized;
  • Financial records are properly maintained;
  • Assets are safeguarded from risks such as waste, abuse, loss, fraud and mismanagement; and
  • Applicable laws, regulations and policies are complied with.

It is important to note that the system of ICFR is not designed to eliminate all risks, rather to mitigate risk to a reasonable level with controls that are balanced with and proportionate to the risks they aim to mitigate.
The system of ICFR is designed to mitigate risks to a reasonable level based on an ongoing process to identify key risks, to assess effectiveness of associated key controls, and adjust as required, as well as to monitor the system in support of continuous improvement. As a result, the scope, pace and status of departmental assessments of the effectiveness of systems of ICFR will vary from one organization to the other based on risks and taking into account their unique circumstances.

1. Introduction

This document is attached to NRC’s Statement of Management Responsibility Including Internal Control over Financial Reporting for the year ended March 31, 2011. As required by the new Treasury Board Policy on Internal Control, effective April 1, 2009, for the first time, this document provides summary information on the measures taken by NRC to maintain an effective system of internal control over financial reporting (ICFR). In particular, it provides summary information on the assessments conducted by NRC as at March 31, 2011, including progress, results and related action plans, as well as financial highlights pertinent to understanding NRC’s unique control environment.

1.1 Authority, Mandate and Program Activities

Detailed information on NRC’s authority, mandate and program activities can be found in its Departmental Performance Report and Report on Plans and Priorities.

1.2 Financial highlights

Financial information can be found in NRC’s audited Financial Statements, Notes to Financial Statements and Financial Statements Discussion and Analysis for fiscal year 2010-2011. Information can also be found in the Public Accounts of Canada.

NRC has a strong regional presence. There is a centralized finance and accounting function which is located not only in headquarters but also in each Institute, Branch and Program across Canada that initiate, process and/or record a significant portion of the financial transactions.

NRC utilizes SIGMA, an SAP-based software as its primary financial system.

1.3 Service arrangements relevant to financial statements

NRC relies on other organizations for the processing of certain transactions that are recorded in its financial statements, such as:

  • Public Works and Government Services Canada (PWGSC) centrally administers the payments of salaries and the procurement of goods and services as per NRC’s Delegation of Authority, provides cheque-issuing services, as well as some accommodations on behalf of NRC;
  • Treasury Board Secretariat (TBS) provides NRC with information used to calculate accruals and allowances such as the accrued severance liability and the Employee Benefits Plan (EBP), and pays the employer’s share of health and dental insurance premiums;
  • Department of Justice provides legal services to NRC;
  • The Office of the Auditor General (OAG) provides audit services to NRC; and
  • Human Resources and Skills Development Canada (HRSDC) pays the employer’s portion of Workers’ Compensation.

1.4 Material changes in fiscal year 2010-2011

The following significant changes within NRC that are relevant to the financial statements occurred in fiscal year 2010-2011:

  • Under Canada's Economic Action Plan announced by the Minister of Finance, NRC received additional funding for the modernization of federal laboratories, for the Federal Contaminated Sites Action Plan and for contributions to support various research and development projects. This initiative has had a significant and temporary increase in activity for the NRC in both fiscal year 2009-2010 and 2010-2011. Refer to the Departmental Performance Report for details;
  • A new President was appointed in April 2010 and a new Chief Financial Officer (CFO) was appointed in the 4th quarter on an acting basis, with an indeterminate appointment in fiscal year 2011-2012;
  • The introduction of monthly forecast updates to replace quarterly budget reviews in order to provide more timely financial information;
  • The implementation of an investment planning process to integrate prioritization planning and resource allocation; and
  • Under the leadership of NRC’s new President, a new strategic plan for NRC was developed with implementation to begin during the 2011-2012 fiscal year.

2. NRC’s control environment relevant to ICFR

NRC recognizes the importance of senior management leadership in ensuring that staff at all levels understand their roles in maintaining effective systems of ICFR and are well equipped to exercise these responsibilities effectively and in ensuring that risks are well managed through a responsive and risk-based control environment that enables continuous improvement and innovation.

2.1 Key positions, roles and responsibilities

Below are NRC’s key positions and committees with responsibilities for maintaining and reviewing the effectiveness of its system of ICFR.

President – NRC’s President, as Accounting Officer, assumes overall responsibility and leadership for the measures taken to maintain an effective system of internal control. In this role, the President is advised by the Departmental Audit Committee and the Senior Executive Committee.

Chief Financial Officer (CFO) – NRC’s CFO reports directly to the President and provides leadership for the coordination, coherence and focus on the design and maintenance of an effective and integrated system of ICFR, including its annual assessment.

Vice-Presidents – NRC’s senior managers in charge of program delivery are responsible for maintaining and reviewing effectiveness of their system of ICFR falling within their mandate.

Chief Audit Executive (CAE) – NRC’s CAE reports directly to the President and provides assurance through periodic internal audits which are instrumental to the maintenance of an effective system of ICFR.

Departmental Audit Committee (DAC) – The DAC is an advisory committee that provides objective views on NRC’s risk management, control and governance frameworks to the President. It is comprised of three external members and it reviews NRC’s Corporate Risk Profile, NRC’s audited financial statements and its system of internal control, including internal and external audit reports and the assessment and action plans related to the system of ICFR.

Senior Executive Committee (SEC) – As NRC’s central decision-making body, SEC reviews, approves and monitors the Corporate Risk Profile and NRC’s system of internal control, including the assessment and action plans related to the system of ICFR. It is comprised of the senior NRC managers and is chaired by the President.

Council – The role of Council is to provide advice to senior management on the operations and performance of NRC. The Council is chaired by the President.

Council Finance Committee – The role of the Council Finance Committee is to provide advice and recommendations to Council regarding the results of the current year budget reviews and initial budget allocations, the financial situation arising from NRC’s multi-year plans, NRC’s investment plan, and other matters that may have a significant impact on NRC’s financial sustainability.

Financial Oversight Committee – The main function of the committee is to review and provide overall advice on risk assessments related to account verification processes and to review quality assurance results, including internal control assessments.

Contract Review Committee – This committee is responsible for the review and/or challenge of proposed contracts to ensure that contracting policies are followed, that prudence and probity are being exercised, and that the contracting process is open, fair and competitive.

2.2 Key measures taken by NRC

NRC has a comprehensive internal control framework over financial management. This framework follows the expenditure management process of the Federal government.

NRC's funding is controlled through a centralized budgeting and commitment control process in its integrated financial system. Contracts and contribution agreements are the subject of a rigorous approval process. NRC’s practices emphasize segregation of duties and common, systematized business processes across all institute, branches and programs

NRC’s expenditures are approved at the expenditure initiation, the performance certification and payment approval stages. Payments are subject to a quality control process that tailors verification processes to risk. Controls over payments are regularly tested for continued and consistent effectiveness.

Financial results are continually monitored through a monthly department-wide financial reporting process validated at each level of management and approved by senior management.
NRC’s control environment also includes a series of measures to equip its staff adequately to manage risks through raising awareness, providing appropriate knowledge and tools as well as developing skills. The most relevant measures are:

  • An established governance structure and strategic direction through the Senior Executive Committee, supported by an advisory Council, and the Departmental Audit Committee;
  • A Conflict of Interest Office under the President, that provides guidance and direction to employees and managers as set out in the NRC’s Conflict of Interest Policy, TBS Values and Ethics Code for Public Service, Statement of Ethical Values and the NRC Values;
  • A Strategic Planning Branch that coordinates and supports department-wide planning, including integrated business planning, risk management, environmental scanning, and preparation of the corporate risk profile approved by the Senior Executive Committee;
  • A division within the Finance Branch and CFO portfolio dedicated to internal control over financial reporting;
  • Regular reporting of financial performance and annual performance agreements which clearly set out financial management responsibilities;
  • Training program and communications in core areas of financial management;
  • Regularly updated delegated authorities matrix;
  • Policies and procedures regarding disciplinary measures in cases of delegation of authority infractions;
  • Secure financial systems to achieve security and integrity of financial data processing, including restricted system access to administrative support based on authorizations and pre-defined roles, that limit access to specific job requirements and meet segregation of incompatible duties principles;
  • Documentation of main business processes and related key risk and control points to support the management and oversight of its system of ICFR;
  • A cascading certification process was introduced, in fiscal year 2005-2006, requiring accountable managers and executives to attest annually to the reliability of the financial information in their area of responsibility;
  • A complete range of human resources, financial and contracting policies tailored to NRC’s control environment, communicated to all levels and supported by formal training sessions;
  • A multi-year risk-based internal audit plan;
  • Transfer payment recipient risk management framework supported by a documented due diligence and authority based business process, mandatory training, and a continuous quality assurance review; and
  • Security Guidelines related to the overall security program including elements of information and personnel security.

3. Assessment of NRC's system of ICFR

3.1 Assessment baseline

NRC’s financial statements have been audited by the OAG since fiscal year 2005-2006. Whether it is to support the control-based audit requirements or those of the Policy on Internal Control, an effective system of ICFR aims to provide reasonable assurance that:

  • Transactions are appropriately authorized;
  • Financial records are properly maintained;
  • Assets are safeguarded; and
  • Applicable laws, regulations and policies are complied with.

Over time, this includes an assessment of the design and operating effectiveness of the system of ICFR leading to an ongoing monitoring program and continuous improvement of NRC’s system of ICFR.

Design effectiveness means:

  • Documentation and assessment of entity level controls;
  • Documentation and assessment of the Information Technology (IT) controls;
  • Documentation of the key processes and related applications to the main accounts;
  • Identification, documentation and assessment of key risk and control points throughout these processes; 
  • Walkthroughs of processes, applications and controls to ensure they are in place and operate as documented;
  • Alignment of controls against the risks they are intended to mitigate; and
  • Remediation to make any adjustments required, including any retest of design effectiveness.

Operating effectiveness means:

  • Development of a risk-based testing plan to identify the key controls to be tested over a defined period of time, including the selection of locations, the test-period as well as the method and frequency of testing;
  • Documentation of results of testing; and
  • Remediation to make any adjustments required, including any retest of operating effectiveness.

An ongoing monitoring program means:

  • All key roles with respect to the ongoing monitoring of the effectiveness of ICFR are defined;
  • A systematic integrated approach to monitoring is in place, including periodic risk-based assessments;
  • Engagement on assessment plans, results and progress with the Departmental Audit Committee and other relevant committees;
  • Timely remediation and related retesting; and
  • Appropriate communication and training of staff.

3.2 Assessment method at NRC

In proceeding with its preparation for the review of its system of ICFR, NRC has taken measures to assess its system of ICFR. NRC followed best practices in the area of internal control frameworks over financial reporting and formally documented its financial management control framework.

NRC identified the following key processes for assessment, taking into consideration its significant financial statements accounts, materiality, risk and other NRC specific factors, including new information available from recent audits and evaluations:

  1. Entity level controls;
  2. General IT controls; and
  3. Business process level controls:
    1. Procurement, payables and payments;
    2. Transfer payments;
    3. Capital assets;
    4. Inventory;
    5. Payroll administration ;
    6. Revenue management;
    7. Financial closing and reporting; and
    8. Financial resource management.

For the three levels of control, NRC has undertaken the following measures:

3.2.1 Entity level controls:

NRC documented and assessed its entity level controls by using the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations (COSO) questionnaire. NRC then proceeded to identify and assess the key controls that mitigate the risks of not achieving the objectives of the system of internal control.

NRC also performed a fraud risk assessment with the objective of identifying the extent to which NRC is exposed to fraud and potential areas of vulnerability, missing or weak controls. The fraud risk assessment is intended to serve as a management tool to support managers in fulfilling their responsibility to be aware of, consider, and mitigate the risk of fraud.

3.2.2 General IT controls:

NRC documented and assessed the operating effectiveness of the general IT controls, which included a review of access to programs and data, program changes, computer operations and program development for financially relevant systems. The assessment was based on the Control Objectives for Business related Information Technology (COBIT) standards.

3.2.3 Business process level controls:

For each key business process and sub-process, NRC completed the following design effectiveness assessment steps:

  • Gathered information pertaining to processes and locations, risks and controls relevant to ICFR, including appropriate policies and procedures;
  • Prioritized the processes and sub-processes based on a risk assessment to focus the documentation on higher risk areas;
  • Developed business process documentation using standard process maps (narrative and flowcharts);
  • Validated all process maps with business process owners and verified that the documented processes corresponded to actual practices;
  • Identified financial statements assertions (objectives), risks and key controls, and assessed residual risk;
  • Ensured appropriate alignment of each key control with the risks they aim to mitigate;
  • Identified, described and prioritized key control deficiencies;
  • Developed a detailed action plan to address required key control deficiencies remediation (e.g. developed recommendations, prioritized deliverables, assigned ownership and accountabilities for remediation work).

NRC developed risk-based testing plans to assess the operating effectiveness of key controls and completed the following operating effectiveness assessment steps:

  • Developed a risk-based testing strategy that identified key controls to be tested over a defined period of time, including the selection of locations, the test-period as well as the method and frequency of testing;
  • Tested the key controls for the transactions selected, to determine if these were operating as intended;
  • Summarized the results and identified any gaps or weaknesses; and
  • Reported on the results and recommended remediation actions to address gaps or weaknesses.

3.3 Ongoing monitoring program at NR

NRC developed ongoing monitoring plans and executed the review of acquisition card transactions, low/medium-risk payment transactions and contribution agreement files on a continuous basis.

NRC started monitoring revenue files during fiscal year 2010-2011 with the objective of gathering evidence on the effectiveness of certain elements of the revenue management internal control framework and for compliance with policies and procedures.

NRC has also been engaging with the Departmental Audit Committee and the Council Finance Committee on assessment plans, results and progress on a regular basis since January 2010.

4. NRC's assessment results

As at fiscal year ended March 31, 2011, NRC completed the testing of design effectiveness, as well as the testing of operating effectiveness on a risk-based approach, and is in the process of implementing remediation actions as required. The following summarizes key assessment results, from the design and operating effectiveness testing completed by NRC to date.

4.1 Entity level controls

The assessment of NRC’s entity level controls concluded that key controls were operating effectively. However, improvement opportunities with regard to the following elements of the application of segregation of duties controls were found:

  • Certain employees have been granted unapproved SIGMA access with conflicting roles per the established management approval process; and
  • A need for increased monitoring for employees with approved SIGMA access with conflicting roles.

4.2 General IT controls

The assessment of the general IT controls concluded that most key controls were operating effectively. However, some weaknesses were found in the IT environment and necessary improvements were identified in the following areas:

  • Improved management approval and formal review process for user access;
  • Improved monitoring of privilege access to SIGMA and the associated databases;
  • A need for effective segregation of duties in the change management process and appropriate access to the development environment; and
  • A need for greater audit trails relative to various IT controls, such as resolution of batch error logs, completed back-up log, evidence of testing on network change request forms, physical access reports and evidence that back-ups are taken off-site.

4.3 Business process controls

4.3.1 Design effectiveness of key controls

NRC assessed the design effectiveness of key controls between 2009 and 2011. The results from the design effectiveness testing identified remediation requirements, which have been or are being pursued in the following key areas:

  • Capital assets: Greater clarity of roles and responsibilities between the financial accounting and the material management processes, and an improved challenge function and quality assurance over capital assets processes to ensure the completeness of costs and an appropriate capitalization date for the capitalization of assets under construction;
  • Revenue: Standardization of business processes across various locations and increased monitoring of revenue files; and
  • Adjusting journal entries: Enhance existing monitoring and review processes for adjusting journal entries.
4.3.2 Operating effectiveness of key controls

In fiscal year 2010-2011, NRC assessed the operating effectiveness of key controls, which identified that most key controls tested were functioning properly. However, improvement opportunities with regard to the operating effectiveness of key financial controls were found in the following areas:

  • Transfer payments: Application of established Section 33 account verification procedures was not applied consistently for low or medium risk contribution agreement claim payments;
  • Capital assets: Some capital asset acquisitions were not recorded with the correct capitalization date, correct amount and / or not properly classified as an asset under construction;
  • Inventory: Physical access was not sufficient to safeguard some inventory for resale; and
  • Revenue: Testing results validated weaknesses identified at the design effectiveness assessment step. As a result, the following remediation requirements have been identified: a need for increased training and communication of certain elements of revenue management practices such as properly documented costing and pricing decisions, improvement in project management practices, and greater clarity in the area of revenue recognition practices.

Testing results have been shared with management and the business process owners. Necessary remediation measures are currently being implemented or planned to be implemented by NRC.

4.4 Ongoing monitoring program

NRC created a dedicated Financial Monitoring Division responsible for managing the documentation and testing of key financial controls, as well as for managing an integrated risk-based approach for the ongoing assessment of NRC’s ICFR. This unit monitors any required remedial actions to its entity level, general IT and business processes controls based on lessons learned from the annual assessments, routine monitoring activities and the results of internal and external audits. This includes ensuring that there is a program in place that raises awareness and understanding of NRC's system of ICFR at all levels, and ensures that employees have the knowledge, skills and tools required to carry out their responsibilities.

The results from the routine monitoring activities identified remediation requirements, which have been or are being pursued in the following key areas:

  • Low/medium risk payment transactions: Testing showed compliance with existing policies. However, certain transactions lacked sufficient documentation to support expenditure initiation authorization and, for some transactions, the appropriate procurement process was not followed;
  • Acquisition card transactions: Testing showed compliance with existing policies. However, some cardholders did not protect the acquisition card number in accordance with NRC policies; and
  • Contribution agreement files: Testing showed compliance with existing policies and business processes. However, some documentation risks were found where some files did not contain evidence of sufficient documentation per established NRC practices.

All findings stated above were communicated to management and stakeholders. Necessary remediation measures are currently being implemented by NRC.

5. NRC's action plan

5.1 Progress as of March 31, 2011

During fiscal year 2010-2011, NRC has continued to make significant progress in assessing and improving its key controls. Below is a summary of the main progress made by NRC. Remediation action taken to date has been aligned in terms of priorities following an assessment of risk.

NRC has completed the following work:

  • Completion of the documentation, design and operating effectiveness testing of all key processes and controls on a risk-based approach;
  • Completion of formal documentation of NRC’s Financial Management Framework;
  • Communication and institution of management actions for circumstances where a policy, regulation or authority has been contravened;
  • Review of the application of standards, development of tools and delivery of training for capitalization of assets of under construction and related eligible expenses;
  • Increased monitoring of payments where the appropriate procurement process may not have been followed; and
  • Developed an approach which links the delegated financial signing authority matrix with a quick reference document in order to clarify contracting policies, authorities and processes.

NRC has substantially advanced the following work:

  • Review of the roles and responsibilities for the monitoring requirements of the capital assets management processes and implementation of the required additional monitoring;
  • Implementation of remediation actions to address gaps between the NRC and the government of Canada payroll administration framework;
  • Implementation of a continuous revenue file monitoring plan;
  • Development of a management action plan resulting from the fraud risk assessment;
  • Control of access to IT programs and data, IT program changes, backup and recovery of data, and improved audit trail relative to various IT controls;
  • Updated documentation and consistent application of Accounts Payable processes to reflect expected quality assurance requirements; and
  • Strengthening and standardization of the processes and procedures to maintain master vendor and customer records.

NRC has commenced or partially completed the following work:

  • Streamlining, strengthening and standardization of key controls between NRC’s Institutes which initiate processes and/or record a significant portion of NRC's revenues; and
  • Reporting and monitoring strategy for conflicting roles in the financial system.

5.2 Action plan for the next fiscal year and future years

The action plan for fiscal year 2011-2012 and subsequent years is to develop and implement a formalized ongoing monitoring program of the effectiveness of NRC’s system of ICFR. This includes monitoring and testing of the operating effectiveness of key financial internal controls, periodic follow-up reviews of entity level and general IT controls, tracking the status of management action plans in response to audit and other recommendations, and reviewing and testing the effectiveness of new controls.

By end of fiscal year 2011-2012, NRC plans to:

  • Continue remediation of the remaining adjustments identified as high priorities;
  • Integrate new key controls as required by any adjustments to its business process and other control levels related to substantive NRC organization changes, including the management of timely testing and remediation as appropriate;
  • Fully develop its ongoing monitoring plans which will include:
    • Updates of business processes, entity level and general IT controls documentation;
    • Updates of risk assessments;
    • Development of a three year risk-based monitoring plan for the selection of accounts and locations, the test-period as well as the method and frequency of testing; and
    • Development of additional ongoing monitoring routines based on risk (including results from fraud risk assessment and other assessments).
  • Continue the ongoing monitoring of the operating effectiveness of its ICFR and report the results of this activity in this annex yearly;
  • Document additional sub-processes identified as lower risk.

Future years:

In fiscal year 2012-2013 and thereafter, NRC will ensure the ongoing monitoring of key controls based on risk. The senior management at NRC is committed to sustaining and continuously improving its sound framework of effective ICFR, including ongoing monitoring to ensure that the key controls meet the expectations of management and stakeholders and appropriately mitigate associated risks.